Can You Keep the Fish You Catch on an Anna Maria Island Fishing Charter? Captain Nate Costello and AMI Excursions

Can You Keep the Fish You Catch on an Anna Maria Island Fishing Charter?

Few things beat finishing a day on the water with fresh fish for dinner. It’s one of the questions I hear most from people booking an Anna Maria Island fishing charter: can we actually take some fish home?

Yes, you can. What you’re allowed to keep depends on the species, the season, the size of the fish, and current Florida regulations. I’m Captain Nate Costello, owner and operator of AMI Excursions, and I spend most of my days fishing these waters. I love helping people put a great meal on the table. I also care a lot about keeping this fishery healthy, so the next group of anglers (and the one after that) gets to enjoy it too.

Keeping Fish on an Anna Maria Island Fishing Charter: The Big Three Inshore Species

When we’re fishing inshore around Anna Maria Island, three fish get most of the attention: snook, spotted seatrout, and redfish. All three are a blast to catch, and all three can make an excellent meal when they’re legally harvested. That said, it’s worth being thoughtful about how many we keep.

Anna Maria Island sits where two Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) management regions meet, Tampa Bay and Sarasota Bay. For the three species below, the rules in both regions currently line up.

Snook

Snook are one of Florida’s most prized inshore fish. You’ll find them around mangroves, passes, docks, and other structure along our coastline. In the Tampa Bay and Sarasota Bay regions, the FWC snook regulations set a slot limit of 28 to 33 inches total length with a bag limit of one fish per person per day.

Snook harvest is seasonal. For 2026, the FWC reopened the season on September 1 in our regions, and it runs through November 30. The spring harvest window runs from March 1 through April 30. Outside those months, snook are catch-and-release only, so always double-check before planning to keep one.

Spotted Seatrout

Trout are another local favorite and some of the best eating fish we catch. The FWC adopted new regional seatrout rules in 2026. In the Tampa Bay and Sarasota Bay regions, the slot limit is 15 to 19 inches with a bag limit of three fish per person per day. You can find the full breakdown on the FWC spotted seatrout page.

Redfish

Few things are more fun than sight-fishing redfish on the shallow flats around the island. The slot limit is 18 to 27 inches. In the Tampa Bay and Sarasota Bay regions, the FWC redfish rules allow one fish per person with a two-fish limit per boat. On a charter, the captain and crew can’t keep a redfish bag limit, so those two fish are all yours.

These limits exist to protect younger fish as well as the big breeding fish that keep the population going. Regulations change, and I keep up with them so you don’t have to, but it’s always smart to check the official FWC pages before your trip.

Why I Recommend Keeping Just Enough for a Meal

Here’s something I encourage every customer to think about: how much fish do you really need? Catching fish is exciting, and bringing home a fresh dinner is part of the fun. But being allowed to keep a fish doesn’t mean you have to keep every fish you’re allowed.

Snook, trout, and redfish are tied closely to our local inshore waters. They do move around, and some make seasonal runs, but many of them spend a big part of their lives in the same areas we fish every day.

Every fish that goes in the cooler is one less fish out there for the next trip. Those fish need to survive, grow, and spawn to keep our fishery productive. When we keep only what we plan to eat and release the rest carefully, we get great fishing today and help protect it for the future.

Honestly, landing a beautiful redfish, snapping a quick photo, and watching it swim off can feel just as good as taking it home. You can see plenty of those moments in our photo gallery.

Offshore Charters: Some of the Best-Tasting Fish in the Gulf

If filling the cooler with fresh seafood is high on your list, an offshore trip is a great way to go. During the fall, winter, and spring, we often run offshore from Anna Maria Island to target some of the best table fare around.

Depending on the season and conditions, that could mean hogfish, gray snapper, mackerel, and a variety of other tasty species. It’s a different experience from fishing the flats, and it can be a great way to bring home a legal catch for dinner. Check out our latest fishing reports to see what’s been biting lately.

Some offshore species pass through our area seasonally. Others stick closer to local reefs and hard bottom. Seasons and limits vary by species, so I keep a close eye on what we’re catching and the rules that apply to each one.

When conditions and regulations line up, heading home with a cooler of legal offshore fish is a great way to wrap up your trip. The key is following the limits and not taking more than you can reasonably use.

We’ll Clean Your Catch and Get It Dinner-Ready

You won’t have to clean your own fish. After the charter, I’ll fillet your legally harvested catch and pack the fillets neatly in zip-top bags so they’re ready to go.

From there, you can cook at your vacation rental or let a local restaurant handle it. A few spots in the area will cook your catch:

Policies and availability can change, so call ahead to confirm before you show up with your fish.

Book Your Anna Maria Island Fishing Charter with AMI Excursions

At AMI Excursions, the goal is to help you enjoy everything that makes fishing here special. Whether we’re working the flats for redfish and trout or heading offshore for hogfish and snapper, I want you to have a great day and make the most of your time on the water.

I’ll walk you through your options for keeping fish, follow the current regulations, and help you enjoy your catch without taking more than you need. Learn more about our Anna Maria Island fishing charters, see what to expect on a private fishing charter, or head to our services and booking page to plan your Anna Maria Island fishing charter today. Questions? Get in touch or call (941) 720-5374.


Frequently Asked Questions

Can I keep the fish I catch on an Anna Maria Island fishing charter?

Yes. You can keep legal fish as long as they meet Florida’s current size limits, bag limits, and seasons for that species. Captain Nate will help you figure out what’s legal to keep on the day of your trip.

What are the redfish limits around Anna Maria Island?

In the Tampa Bay and Sarasota Bay management regions, redfish must be between 18 and 27 inches. The limit is one per person with a maximum of two per boat. Captain and crew can’t keep a redfish bag limit on a charter trip.

When is snook season near Anna Maria Island?

In the Tampa Bay and Sarasota Bay regions, snook harvest is open March 1 through April 30 and September 1 through November 30. The slot limit is 28 to 33 inches, with one fish per person per day. Outside those dates, snook are catch-and-release only.

How many spotted seatrout can I keep?

Under the FWC rules that took effect in 2026, you can keep three trout per person per day in the Tampa Bay and Sarasota Bay regions, as long as they measure 15 to 19 inches.

Will the captain clean my fish?

Yes. After your trip, Captain Nate fillets your legally harvested fish and packages the fillets in zip-top bags for you to take home.

Can a restaurant on Anna Maria Island cook my catch?

Yes. The Waterfront Restaurant offers a “You Catch, We Cook” option, and The Feast Restaurant and Mar Vista on Longboat Key are also known for preparing anglers’ catches. Call ahead to confirm current policies.

What fish can I keep on an offshore charter?

Depending on the season and regulations, offshore trips from Anna Maria Island often produce hogfish, gray snapper, mackerel, and other great-eating species. Limits vary by species, and Captain Nate keeps track of what’s legal.


Sources

Be sure to share this great article!